The company has a right to try to prevent further action against them, but we think buyers should know about this Arbitration Agreement before buying. It is not typical of the small print that usually comes with cookware. But we do have one cuisinart knife telling piece of evidence to share here, and that is the Arbitration Agreement that came with the pan. This is a long disclaimer that basically says if you buy the pan, you enter into an agreement not to sue the company for any reason.
These thick-gauge hard-anodized aluminum pans heat evenly and cook delicate foods just as well as a $130 tri-ply nonstick skillet. They also work on all cooktops, including induction (though their bonded steel base doesn’t heat as evenly as the multi-layer encapsulated bottom on the Tramontina Tri-Ply pan). The 10-inch B1 pan is heftier than our top pick (it’s almost 3 pounds, whereas the Tramontina Professional weighs about 2 pounds). But the comfortable rounded handles and excellent balance make both All-Clad B1 pans easy to maneuver.
Bakeware is also aluminum with the original titanium ceramic coating. But if you buytoocheap, your pans will be too thin and lightweight, and aren’t going to have very good heating properties. This will result in uneven heating and scorching that can make cooking frustrating. Other than the Original line, all the Gotham Steel pans have an encapsulated base to make them induction compatible. This base also adds to the pan’s durability, making it much less prone to warp than if they didn’t have the extra base.
If you are interested in trying the brand out, this is definitely a good way to test the waters. While it is technically “dishwasher safe,” many owners reported that the nonstick function of the pan was diminished after repeated Cookware Sets dishwasher use. ULTRA NONSTICK – our award winning ceramic and titanium coating ensures the ultimate easy release — everything just slides right off the… From muffins to french fries, you’ll be able to cook it all.
All the cookware has great design and looks more expensive than it is. At Hiya.com, Gotham Steel gets an average rating of 1.5/5 stars. This is based on ratings and reviews from actual users, which you can click over and read for yourself. The environmental concerns gotham steel cookware sets are probably still real, and it’s worth avoiding PTFE cookware for this reason alone. The truth is, though, that the PFOA is used up in the manufacturing process, so you are more likely to get PFOA from your drinking water than you are from your cookware.
In all likelihood, this set won’t last you the entire 10 years. But if you want an affordable and comprehensive set of non-stick cookware, this set might be worth it. If you need something to prevent food from sticking, use an oil with a higher smoke point or butter.